
"I am the city of knowledge, Ali is its door" Is this a fake hadith? 9815579575
Ahle Haq Bangla Media Service•sirat and history•
Question
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
Ibn 'Abbas said: The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said: He said, "The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said, 'I am the city of knowledge and' Ali is its gate. ' The person who wants to acquire knowledge should enter through the door. The hadith is narrated in the books of Almuzamul Kabir, Hadith No. 11061. Mustadrake Hakem, Hadith No. 4836. Kanzul Ummal, Hadith No. 32790. Almusnadul Jame, Hadith No. 10339. Sunan Tirmidhi, Hadith No. 3623 There are many words of this hadith in the Muhaddithin. Many have called it a fabrication. Many have commented that Zayef. However, many have recognized it as Sanad Sahih or Hasan level Hadith. E.g.-
- Allama Sakhabi said: The hadith is Hasan. (Almakasidul Hasan, Narration No. 123)
- Allama Yarkani said that the hadith narrated from Hazrat Ibn Abbas is Hasan Linafsihi, and the narration from Hazrat Ali is Hasan Ligairihi. (Mukhtasarul Makasid, Narration No. 160)
- Allama Shawqani said: The hadith is Hasan Ligairihi. (Al-Fawaidul Majmoo ', Narration No. 349)
- Allama Hakeem Nishapuri said: The sanad of this hadith is saheeh. (Mustadrake Hakem, Hadith No. 4838)Since the Imams of more than one acceptable Jarah Tadil have commented that the hadith is saheeh, hasan, it is not expedient to dismiss this narration as fabricated. 2166852745
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Related Fatwas
- Shaykh al-Albani's Arrogant Interference in Fake Hadith Rulings and Hadith Books 7294349945
- When no hadith source is found ... 5429788466
- What is the ruling on cooperating with the so-called Ahl al-Hadith? 3215747115
- Response to the propaganda about Ashraf Ali Thanbi made by Rasulullah Ki Noor 3256385351
- Unmasking the Ahl al-Hadith community and dispelling their misconceptions 2624145551
- Why the Taqlid of the four Imams instead of the Taqlid of the four Caliphs 3496624646
- A chapter of knowledge is better than a thousand years of worship whether one wants to learn it or not. ”Is this a hadith? 7182911839
- Is there shirk in the introduction of Fazayel to the falsehood of the so-called Ahl al-Hadith? 8883129213