
Is it possible to impose the rules of Hadith by looking at the books of Hadith? 3958876597
Ahle Haq Bangla Media Service•education•
Question
I saw in Bulugul Maram that various Zayf Hadiths have been brought. Of course, some hadiths have martyred hadiths. But what should I do in the case of all the hadiths about which there is no Shahed Hadith but which have been declared "Zayf" by showing more documents in the commentary? Will I act on them or not? Again, there is a difference of opinion about many Zayf hadiths. Which one should I take? 1431215241
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
Not everyone has the right to read medical books. Similarly, not everyone has the right to impose rulings by reading books of Hadith. The ability to read medical books and impose provisions is like that of a wise doctor. If a hammer doctor or a common person starts treatment in the light of a medical book, the number of deaths of such patients will increase. In the same way, if the inexperienced scholars and muhaddiths impose rulings on the verses and hadiths containing the rules, the whole religion will be almost dead. So he should be allowed to do it. Which hadith will you accept? Which hadith to exclude? Learn about this hadith from wise and prudent hadith scholars. It would be foolish to read a book ordered by a muhaddith just by saying Sahih Zayef. Therefore, in this case, it is not just Bulugul Maram, but in the case of any book of Hadith, the rule of Hadith containing the advice and guidance of wise people cannot be said. Rather, one should seek the help of a person who is knowledgeable about the hadith. He has to see the sanad of the hadith. You have to see the words of Keram in Muhaddisin. Who said this hadith is acceptable? Who called it pioneering? And why? After reviewing everything, a decision can be made about that hadith. It is as dangerous and terrible to start treatment as it is to start treatment by looking at a medical book of an ordinary educated person. Therefore, in this case, no order can be imposed without the help of wise scholars. 8331576787
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Related Fatwas
- Shaykh al-Albani's Arrogant Interference in Fake Hadith Rulings and Hadith Books 7294349945
- What is the ruling on looking at other people's books in the exam? 7694125195
- The difference between Hadith and Fiqh 9276572551
- Looking at the mother with the eyes of mercy is the reward of accepted Hajj 1516776374
- Reading Ayatollah Kursi after prayers 6244592676
- Definition and types of hadith: What are the hadiths about the Sahabah and the followers? 5764219848
- What to do if the book of Hadith falls from the hand 5298547236
- When no hadith source is found ... 5429788466