Is the word "ink of a scholar's pen more valuable than the blood of martyrs" a hadith? 8957677144
Ahle Haq Bangla Media Service•miscellaneous•
Question
Is the word "ink of a scholar's pen more valuable than the blood of martyrs" a hadith? 8545223528
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
The Arabic text of that statement is, Madad al-Ulama is better than the blood of the martyrs: the ink of the wise is better than the blood of the martyrs. Keram's comment on the statement in Muhaddisin:
- Mollah Ali Kari Rah: Some people say that it has no basis, or it is fake. (Al-Asrarul Marfua, Narration No. 303)
- Allama Mari Al-Karmi said: This is actually the statement of Hazrat Hasan Basri. (Alfawaidul Mauzua, Narration No. 106)
- Allama Yarkani said, this is the statement of Hasan Basri. It is called Marfu. (Mukhtasarul Makasid, Narration No. 928)
- Allama Ibn al-Jawzi said: It is not a hadith. (Alilalul Mutanahiya-1/60)The statement of the muhaddithin proves that this statement is not a hadith of Hazrat Hasan Basri. Therefore, it will not be permissible to call it the Hadith of the Prophet (peace be upon him). 7399312353
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Related Fatwas
- Are the Muslims who died in the war of independence in 1971 not martyrs? 8267485727
- The first martyr of Islam 8247356454
- Is it better to go out in the way of Allah one morning / one afternoon than what is between the world and the world? 9632785112
- Reading the janaza of more than one death together 3797435281
- To sell blood 9285975252
- The condition for being a scholar is to do the work of preaching 8471459973
- A chapter of knowledge is better than a thousand years of worship whether one wants to learn it or not. ”Is this a hadith? 7182911839
- Is the hadith correct in the sense that the world is the field of the Hereafter? 8662852327