
Question
Is it necessary to perform Ifrad Hajj for Badli Hajj? Many people say that it is important to make a difference. Even if the sender allows Tamattu or Kiran Hajj, it will not be realized. Ifrad Hajj has to be done. The same has been said in the book Muallimul Hujjaj. Again, some scholars are heard to say that it is permissible. I would like to know the proper solution in this regard. 7258116316
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
If the sender gives permission, the substitute Tamattu and Kiran can also perform Hajj. It is not permissible to do ifrad even if there is permission, tamattu or kiran is not permissible. In some books, including Muallimul Hujjaj and Fatawa Khaliliyah, Ifrad is said to be urgent in all cases, but many Muftis of the subcontinent have issued fatwas saying that it is permissible to perform Tamattu and Kiran with the permission of the sender. For example, Mufti Kefayatullah Dehlavi rah., Mufti Muhammad Shafi rah. And Mufti Zafar Ahmad Usmani rah., Mufti Rashid Ahmad Ludhianvi rah. Etc. And there is a clear decision from the Hanafi jurists to be permissible. For example, Fatawa Khaniya, Allama Sindhi's Lubab, Allama Saeed Abdul Ghani's Irshadus Sari and Allama Ibn Abedin Shami in Fatawa Shami have decided that if the permission is granted, the transferee Kiran, Tamattu can do anything. It is not necessary to perform Ifrad Hajj. Besides, it is also mentioned in Mabsut Sarakhsi and Hedayat that Kiran is permissible. 3617141532
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Source
- লুবাবুল মানাসিক, Page: 459
- ফাতাওয়া খানিয়া, Part: 1, Page: 307
- মাবসূত সারাখসী, Part: 4, Page: 155
- হেদায়া, Part: 1, Page: 298
- রদ্দুল মুহতার, Part: 2, Page: 611
- ইমদাদুল আহকাম, Part: 2, Page: 183
- আহসানুল ফাতাওয়া, Part: 4, Page: 523
- কেফায়াতুল মুফতী, Part: 4, Page: 45
- জাওয়াহিরুল ফিকহ, Part: 1, Page: 508
- ফাতাওয়া উছমানী, Part: 2, Page: 222
Related Fatwas
- In case of Badli Hajj, to perform Tamattu or Ifrad Hajj by disobeying the sender 5748489189
- What to do when menstruation starts during Hajj 7562649211
- Whether the obligatory Hajj is performed by performing Hajj with the money of Hadia? 2357257178
- Badli is a suitable person for Hajj 2574615883
- The difference between substitute Hajj and obligatory Hajj 2887472313
- At the same time performing Hajj and obligatory Hajj of Mannat 2478791257
- Performing obligatory Hajj by performing Hajj by borrowing 8843735466
- Performing Hajj Tamattu after going to Makkah wearing Ihram for the purpose of Badli Hajj 8778436125