
Question
I live in Chittagong. For some reason, the last Eid of Qurbani has to be celebrated in an orphanage in Dhaka. Sacrifice was no longer obligatory on me as I was a traveler. But since my wife and eldest daughter are Sahib Nasab, I bought a cow on their behalf for the purpose of sacrificing and I want to give the meat to the orphanage with their permission. I heard the night before Eid that a cow would be slaughtered before Fajr. Because there are many students who do not have access to food, food has to be prepared for them in advance and it is given to the students in the pickup van. According to the rules, my cow was slaughtered 25 minutes before the Fajr prayer and it was cooked and given to the students. I would like to ask Huzur whether it is permissible to slaughter my cow before the Eid prayers while he is a traveler, and whether the sacrifice of my wife and daughter has been realized by it? 9387775934
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
That sacrifice was not valid. Because in all the places where Eid prayers are held (whether it is in the city or in the village) the time of Qurbani comes only after the Eid prayers are offered in one of the places in the area. There is no time for sacrifice before this. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: Who slaughtered before the prayer, so that it may be the last, and who was not slaughtered until we prayed. He who has made a sacrifice before the Eid prayer (he has not made a sacrifice) should make another sacrifice instead. And whoever did not slaughter before our Eid prayers, let him slaughter now in the name of Allah. (Sahih Bukhari, Hadith 5500) So the sacrifice of your wife and daughter was not realized. Now they have to give two goats or their value as charity instead of sacrificing them. Note that the area in which the sacrifice is made is considered to be the area in time. It does not matter whether the sacrificer is a traveler or a muqeem. 9514245295
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Source
- শরহু মুখতাসারিত তাহাবী, Part: 7, Page: 336
- সারাখসী, Part: 12, Page: 10
- বাদায়েউস সানায়ে, Part: 4, Page: 211
- তাবয়ীনুল হাকায়েক, Part: 6, Page: 477
- ফাতাওয়া তাতারখানিয়া, Part: 17, Page: 419
- আদ্দুররুল মুখতার, Part: 6, Page: 318
Related Fatwas
- Qaya of Asr prayer can be performed before Fajr prayer Qaya of Asr prayer can be performed before Maghrib prayer 2143983667
- Sacrifice before Eid 6151611843
- Ruling on reciting the Sunnah when the Fajr Jama'at begins 1625946681
- Fajr sunnat time and qayaar hukum 2682593356
- Accepting the sacrificer of the sacrifice 5611714694
- Why two sacrifices for the poor 2786538134
- Sacrifice of partnership 2717568332
- If the congregation of Eid is at different times, then the sacrifice is valid 1193629113