
Question
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
It is not lawful to make a will for an heir (ie, those who have a share in the estate of the deceased). Even if you make a will, it will not be effective. Of course, a will can be made for those who are not heirs. If someone does, it will be necessary to implement it from one third of the resources. Prominent Companion Abu Umama Bahili. He said, "I heard the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) say in his Farewell Hajj speech that Allaah has given his right to every rightful owner." Therefore, a will cannot be made for an heir. In another narration, there is no provision of will for the heir. So in the case in question, the will that your uncle made for his uncle is valid, but it is not lawful to make a will for the child. So it will not be effective. It is clear that although it is not valid to make a will for a child and other heirs, it would be permissible for someone to do so, and if all the other heirs are adults and they all want to carry out the will completely spontaneously. Hazrat Abdullah bin Abbas. He said that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said that it is not valid to make a will for the heirs, but it will be valid if the other heirs give permission. It is further stated that since the will is not valid for the heirs, the land bequeathed to the child will be considered as the inherited property of all the heirs. And according to the details of the question, since the land bequeathed to the uncle is less than one-third of the total property of the testator, he will be entitled to it according to the will. 6284284388
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Source
- মুসনাদে আহমদ, Part: 4, Page: 186
- সুনানে দারাকুতনী, Part: 4, Page: 98
- সুনানে বায়হাকী, Part: 6, Page: 263
- জামে তিরমিযী, Hadith No.: 2,126
- জামে তিরমিযী, Hadith No.: 2,022
- সুনানে ইবনে মাজাহ, Hadith No.: 2,008
Related Fatwas
- What will be the method of distribution of wealth between mother, father, siblings, wives 4844276261
- Conditions for the will to be valid 9994527656
- Performing Hajj by a person residing in Makkah 7546932698
- The amount of wealth to make Hajj obligatory on both husband and wife 9957139688
- Paying Zakat on the assumption of excess of wealth 5898725823
- In the context of several masalas and principles of distribution relating to inheritance 2177925751
- Abu Bakr and Umar (may Allah be pleased with them all) spent in the way of religion 2221179743
- Praying with hair tied up 8567921869