
Question
Nowadays, due to the crowd, mahram men are the ones who do the work of throwing stones on behalf of many women. Is it correct? Again, many women did not come to Muzdalifah's field due to the crowd and came directly to the Minar tent and spent the night. The mahram men also came with him. Want to know if it would be permissible? Will any breath be obligatory in this? 9681277323
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
It is not lawful to throw stones at others for the sake of the crowd. This will not fulfill their obligation. Although it is crowded during the day, it is not so crowded at night. Rami is a good time for women and the weak at night. It is revealed that it is permissible to perform Rami with another only when the pilgrim is unable to reach Jamra and perform Rami due to illness. If it is lawful for him to pray while he is ill, then he can do rumi with another person, not otherwise. And for the sake of the crowd, women are allowed to go directly from Arafa to Mina without Uqf Muzdalifah. It will not be obligatory on them. But now that the minaret tents of the Bangladeshi pilgrims are mainly within the borders of Muzdalifah, even if the minaret goes directly to that tent from Arafa, Muzdalifah will be realized in the Uquf of all. But it would be better for the able-bodied to perform Uqf under the open sky near the Masjid Haram in the mosque. 8253182522
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Related Fatwas
- Sacrifice on behalf of others 5888955535
- Whether a sacrifice made on behalf of one family will be realized on behalf of all 4935622915
- What to do if you can't throw stones because of weight 9975228349
- Rami with others and Rami before sunrise or after sunset 5424583461
- The continuance of throwing stones, sacrifices and shaving the head during Hajj 8933385244
- Performing Hajj on behalf of the deceased without a will 9946962978
- History of Hazare Aswad 5742138412
- Sacrifice of the father on behalf of the affluent child 2872673427