salat Fatwa Cover

What to do if the Imam's Qur'an is impure 9381236177

Monthly Al Kawtharsalat


Question

If it is not saheeh to pray behind the imam (that is, his qiraat is wrong and impure), then can the congregation pray behind him on his own initiative for fear of sedition while he is in the congregation? I will be benefited if you provide me with detailed documents and evidence. 2723854757


Answer

- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -

It is necessary to have a recitation according to the Tajweed, but any kind of mistake in the recitation does not ruin the prayer; On the contrary, if the Qur'an is misread and its meaning is distorted in a way that is completely contrary to the facts or information given in the Qur'an, or if the meaning that has been created due to a mistake becomes anti-faith, then the prayer will be ruined. Therefore, in case of error in the recitation of the Imam, it is important to inform the wise scholar or a Mufti about the type of that impure recitation without taking any decision on one's own. This will prevent you from coming to the wrong conclusion. If it is proved in reality that the qiraat of the Imam is so impure that it spoils the prayer, then if there is a danger of fitna, he will offer the prayer behind that Imam during the congregation. Later he will recite that prayer alone again. But in this situation one should not stand alone in the congregation behind the Imam and pray alone. 7285794157

- والله اعلم باالصواب -

* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here

Source

  • সহীহ বুখারী, Part: 1, Page: 76
  • ফাতহুল বারী, Part: 2, Page: 18
  • জামে তিরমিযী, Part: 1, Page: 43
  • মুসান্নাফ ইবনে আবী শায়বা, Part: 4, Page: 146
  • ফাতাওয়া হিন্দিয়া, Part: 1, Page: 79
  • রদ্দুল মুহতার, Part: 1, Page: 631
  • শরহুল মুনইয়াহ, Page: 476