
Question
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
It is a Shari'ah command to perform janaza once for any deceased. It is not lawful to perform janaza more than once. However, if the janaza is performed without their permission in the absence of the guardians of the deceased, then they are allowed to perform the janaza a second time. Therefore, in the case in question, since the sons of the deceased were present in the first congregation, it was not right for the relatives to offer the janaza prayer for the second time. The matter is proved by the words and deeds of the Companions and the Tabi'is. Nafe Ra. Narrated from Hazrat Abdullah bin Umar. If he had been present after the janaza prayer, he would have left after praying (for the deceased). He did not perform janaza for the second time. (Musannaf Abdur Razzaq 3/519) In another narration, the famous Tabi'i Ibrahim Rah. He said that janaza of a dead person cannot be performed twice. (Musannaf Ibn Abi Shaybah 6/420) In another narration, the famous Tabei Hasan Basri rah. If he never got the janaza prayer, he would only apologize for the dead. (Above) So the janaza of any deceased can be read only once. And those who have not received the janaza will pray and apologize for the dead according to the rules of the Companions. This is the teaching of the law. 2871557629
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Source
- ইলাউস সুনান, Part: 8, Page: 288
- শরহু মুখতাসারিত তহাবী, Part: 2, Page: 218
- আযযখীরা, Part: 2, Page: 472
- কিতাবুল উম্ম, Part: 1, Page: 314
- আলমাবসূত, সারাখসী, Part: 2, Page: 67
- আলবাহরুর রায়েক, Part: 2, Page: 181
- বাদায়েউস সানায়ে, Part: 2, Page: 47
- ফাতাওয়া হিন্দিয়া, Part: 1, Page: 163
- রদ্দুল মুহতার, Part: 2, Page: 223
Related Fatwas
- Did not the meraj of the Prophet (peace be upon him) happen in a dream while awake in his body? 6511332519
- Regarding the janaza of the Prophet (peace be upon him) and the death of Hazrat Fatima (peace be upon him) 7154242933
- Answers to some of the most common questions about madhhabs 5697116394
- Bukhari's account of the Prophet's attempted suicide 2857131816
- Judging by the analysis, where is the problem to follow one madhhab at a time 8199937162
- Musafaha how many hands with one hand or two hands 1434965929
- Tahkeek of the hadith found in the light of light and the nonsense of the claimants of light 7124991651
- Akika of the dead child 6796153392