How are the four Madhhabs right together? 8259736196

In this regard, I think it is appropriate to share a conversation with some of the so-called Ahl al-Hadith with Munazir Islam Muhammad Amin Ukarbi. I hope you will get a clear answer to your question during the conversation, inshallah. Once upon a time some people of the so-called Ahl al-Hadith came to Muhammad Amin Safdar. He came and sat near Hazrat. "We are in a lot of trouble," he said. I am very upset." Safdar Rah:- “Those who leave the elders, they are in trouble all their lives. Maududi was in this predicament. Qadiani was also in this predicament. You also seem to want to understand everything yourself, leaving the elders. That's why you are in pereshani". Alleged Ahl al-Hadith - Four Imams. Four, four, four. What do we do? Safdar: Where did you find four people here? There is no shame here. Neither is Shafeei. Neither is Maleki. The so-called Ahle Hadith - if there are four! Safdar Rahah-Hala is a different story. Why are you pulling the trouble now? The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - how is it that Allah is one and Imams are four? Safdar: How is it that Allah is one and there are one hundred and twenty four thousand prophets? As it is said there, respect one prophet and leave the rest. Same thing here. Respect an imam. Leave the rest. Is there somewhere or that, the imam can not be more? If there is, I will accept. I see Imam can be more as proved by Quran. وَلَقَدْ اطَيْنَا مُوسَى الْكِتَابَ فَلا تَكُنْ فِي مِرْيَةٍ مِنْ لِقَائِهِ وَجَعَلْنَاهُ هُدىً لِبَنِي إِسْرايلَ وَجَعَلْنَا مِنْهُمْ اَئِمَّةً يَهْ دُونَ بِأَمْرِنَا That is, the truth is We gave Moses the Book, so (O Messenger!) do not be in any doubt about meeting him. We made the Book a guidance for the Children of Israel. And We made some of them Imams who would guide people according to My instructions. (Surah Sajda-23,24) There may be some Imams among the Ummah of a Prophet. This is what the Quran says. The plural form of the Qur'anic word imam is used as Ayyimmah. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - four imams are correct? Safdar - Yes, all four imams are correct. Why do not the so-called Ahl al-Hadith follow the four Imams? Why just follow your imam? Safdar Rah: As everyone accepts one hundred and twenty four thousand Prophets as correct, but we follow our Prophet. Likewise, the four Imams are correct. But follow your imam. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - which hadiths are there or follow an imam? Safdar Rah:- you read the Quran? So called Ahl al-Hadith - read yes. Safdar Rahah-Ek Kerate? Or seven times? Alleged Ahl Hadith-Ek Kerate? Safdar Rah:- Is there anywhere in the Quran or Hadith to read the Quran in one kerat and leave the rest of the kerat? The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - we have it. so read But if you follow one imam, a quarter of the deen is accepted. Safdar Rah:- If you read the Qur'an in one kerat, do you get a reward of one part of seven? According to the Ahl al-Hadith - no, no, reciting in one Qiraat is the reward of reciting the full Quran. Safdar R.H. If one follows such an Imam, then the full Shariah is followed. The so-called Ahle Hadith-you will never have a mind? There is a difference between the imams about haram and halal. What one calls halal, the other calls it haram. Then the one who says haram is also correct. And the one who says halal is also correct! How is this possible? Safdar - Alhamdulillah! Allah has given wisdom. All prophets are right. It is permissible to marry one's sister during the time of Adam. Haram in our religion. But both prophets are right. Two of Yakub's wives were his sisters. It was legal at the time. But it is forbidden in the religion of our Prophet. Both are correct. God is the same for everyone. But the order is different. All the four imams are correct. But their orders may vary. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - here is the matter of Nasekh Mansukh. One decree came and abrogated the other. The matter of Rajeh-Marjuh between Safdar Rah-A and Imams Ikhtilaf. Hence the issue of giving priority to one order over another. Just as it is not permissible to act on an abrogated matter, it is also not permissible to act on a matter of non-priority by keeping a priority order. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - since you do not respect other imams, then why do not you reject them? Why do you say correct? If Safdar rah-Adam ah is the right prophet, why can't the sister be married? If Yakub is the right prophet, why can't two sisters be married together? Said Ahl al-Hadith - We only obey our Prophet. The rest are also right. Safdar: We also say that other imams are fine, but we accept our imam. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - the time is different there. Safdar Road:- Here the area is different. Shafi'i in Sri Lanka and Hanafi in Pakistan (Bangladesh). The time is different there, and the area is different here. So-called Ahl al-Hadith - If three imams are on one side and one imam is on one side, then what to do? Safdar Rah:- If not three people, but three thousand, accept our imam. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - is this fair? Safdar Rah: Of course it is fair. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith-are three imams on the other hand. Safdar Rah: What is it? We will follow our Imam. What if three thousand? The so-called Ahl al-Hadith - are you insisting or not? Safdar Rah: No, why insist? Is it in the Quran that Yusuf prostrated to his father Yaqub? According to the Ahl al-Hadith - yes. In the interpretation of Safdar, the mufassirs say that before the prophethood of the Holy Prophet, it was permissible to prostrate in respect to all the prophets. On the one hand, one hundred and twenty-three thousand and nine hundred and ninety-nine hundred and ninety-nine are permissible for the Prophet. And another Prophet Muhammad SAW says it is not permissible. You are talking about three people. Here is a matter of lakhs. Who will obey? A large congregation? No one? The Mufassirs say that drawing pictures with bodies was permissible in the Shariah of all the Prophets. It is not permissible only in the law of our Prophet. Then one hundred and twenty-three thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine will not obey the law of our one prophet? More than one person? Eating sacrificial meat was not permissible in anyone's Shariah before our Prophet. So who will obey? Millions of prophets or our one prophet? The so-called Ahl al-Hadith (be silent for a while) religion came to Makkah-Madinah? Not in Kufa? Safdar Rahah-Mecca-Medina. The so-called Ahl al-Hadith-then the imam of Makkah-Madinah should not be followed by the imam of Kufa? Safdar: What does your mind say? The so-called Ahle Hadith-Imams of Makkah-Madinah should be obeyed. Safdar: You have told a big lie. It will never be forgiven. The alleged Ahl hadith-mistakes? Safdar Rah: Yes, very big. The so-called Ahle Hadith-how? Safdar Rahah-Quran has not been revealed in Makkah-Madinah? Alleged Ahl al-Hadith-Yes. Safdar Rahah-There were seven people. Among them there was the Qari of Makkah-Madinah. There was also the Qari of Basra. But why does everyone read the Qur'an in Qari Asim Kufir? If you read the Qur'an in the Qur'an of Kufi Qari, who is more Kufi than you? The Quran was revealed in Makkah-Madinah and the infidels read the Korat! How about that? The people of the so-called Ahl al-Hadith-Kufa did not make the Quran themselves. The Companions who came to Kufa brought the Quran with them. Safdar R.H.-If the Companions from Makkah-Madinah did not take the Qur'an to Kufa and make it new, then did the Sahabahs from Makkah-Madinah take it to Kufa and make it a new prayer? The long tongue of the so-called Ahle Hadith was silenced. 3373429659