
What is the real name of Bukhari Muslim and Tirmidhi? 1363846964
Ahle Haq Bangla Media Service•miscellaneous•
Question
Answer
- حامداومصلياومسلما، بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم -
Sometimes the surname and social name of something gains such fame that people forget its real name. Such as Abu Hurairah R. What is his real name? There are about 50 names in this regard from Muhaddisin Keram. But what other name could be above the name that the Prophet (peace be upon him) called? However, as a journalist writes the headline of his news in such a way that the gist of the news is understood by looking at the headline, it is understood what is discussed in the news? This is how an author names his book. It is as if the subject matter and purpose of the book are revealed by the name. For this reason, it is very important to know the name of a book. Bukhari, Muslim and Tirmidhi. World famous Hadith books. The name Sifati has become so popular that many of us are unaware of its name. Bukhari Sharif We call this book Bukhari Sharif, Sahih Bukhari or just Bukhari. 1 In Muhaddisin, many people have given the name of Bukhari Sharif on their own behalf. As many have written the name "Aljameus Sahih". This name can be called Sifat of Bukhari Sharif. But this is not the name given by Imam Bukhari. 2 Again, many have written the name of the book to highlight or shorten it. For example, the famous Maliki Fakbih Qazi Yaz Rah: Bukhari Sharif's name is written in the book "Masharikul Anwar Ala Sihahil Asar" "Al Jameul Musnad Assahih Almukhtasar Min Asari Rasulillahi Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam". Kazi Yaz Rah: The name has been abbreviated a bit and the name has been added on its own behalf. Hafez Ibn Hazar Askalani, the famous commentator of Bukhari Sharif, has written the name of Bukhari in Fathul Bari's Muqaddima "Hadyus Sari": (Hadyus Sari-1/6) Ibn Hazar Asqalani: Mutaakhkhirin Samasin in the status of superiority among the muhaddisin. But adults also stumble from time to time. In this case Ibn Hazar Askalani has made a slight mistake. The way he said the name, Imam Bukhari did not put Bukhari's name in the exact word. 4 Hafez Abu Nasr Alkalabaji Rah (died 396 AH) wrote the name of Bukhari Sharif on page 24 of his book "Rizalu Sahihil Bukhari": 5 The famous muhaddis, fuqahih qazi Abu Muhammad Abdul Haq bin Atiya Undulusi Rah (died 541 AH) wrote the name of Bukhari Sharif in his book "Fehreste Ibn Atiyah". (Fahrest Ibn Atiyah-45) Imam Nawabi also said the same name, that is, "Al-Jameel Musnad Assahih Al-Mukhtasar Min Umuri Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam Wasunanihi Waayamihi". (Tahajibul Asma'i Wallugat-1/63) The same name has been mentioned by Hafez Ibn Salah. (Muqaddimaye Ibn Salah-24/25) The same name is also written by Hafez Ibn Rashid Al-Basti. (Ifadatut Tasheeh Fittarifi Bisanadil Jameis Saheeh-18) (Umdatur Kari-1/5) So what is understood? The original name of Bukhari Sharif is "Aljameul Musnad Assahih Almukhtasar Min Umuri Rasoolullah Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam Wasunanihi Waayamihi". Muslim Sharif is said to be the most authentic book after Bukhari. Many muhaddiths also prefer Muslims over Bukhari. Because Imam Muslim has been so careful not to mention anything other than his own book Hadith that he has not established any title in that book on his behalf. For this reason, this book has been quoted without any title. Moreover, more than one sanad of one hadith has been collected among the Muslims. By reading which the statement of the charter and all the issues of the charter come to the fore. Which is not found in Bukhari. There is more confusion with the name of Muslim than the name of Bukhari. Most of them call me Muslim Sharif for short. If someone writes the name seriously, then write that "Almusnadus Sahih". That's all. What about others? Imam Muslim himself has mentioned only the name "Almusnad" in one place of his book and "Almusnadus Sahih" somewhere in his book for the sake of brevity. 1 Muhammad bin Masarji (may Allah be pleased with him) said: I have heard Muslim bin Hujjaj (may Allah be pleased with him) say that I have selected and written this Musnadus Sahih book from three lakh hadiths. (Fahrest Ibn Atiyah) 2 Allama Khatib Baghdadi wrote the name of Sahih Muslim - "Almusnadus Sahih". (Dated Baghdad-13/100) The same name is said by Hafez Ibn Manjuah Isfahani. (Rizalu Sahih Muslim-1/29) 3 Imam Muslim Rah: Somewhere in the name of his book only Musnad wrote. Since Sahih Hadith has been quoted in both Bukhari Muslim texts. Therefore, in the later muhaddithin, the scholars refer to Bukhari as "Aljameus Sahih" and Muslim as "Almusnadu Sahih" to distinguish between the two books. (Imam Hakimkrat “Tasmiyatu Man Akhrajahumul Bukhari Wamuslim-35) 4 Imam Ibn Atiyah writes in the list of Ibn Atiyah: 5 Qazi Ayaz (may Allah be pleased with him) wrote: (Masharikul Anwar Ala Sihahil Asar-1/10) There is no word "Sunan" in this definition. বনে Hafiz Ibn Khair writes the name of Ash-Shabili Muslim Sharif, (Marwahu an Shuyukhuhu-9 in Fahres) This is the original name of Muslim Sharif. Tirmizi Sharif Tirmizi's condition is not less than Sahihain. His real name can be said to have been erased from people's minds. The same sentence can be heard in the brains of those who read and teach, the name of this book is Tirmizi. First of all, the controversy over this book. Is it Sunan or Jame? Shaykh Nasruddin Albani was the first to divide Tirmidhi into two parts. One part was named Sahih Tirmizi, the other part was named Zayef Tirmizi. No muhaddith has done this indecent act before. No one has shown the audacity to share a book compiled by a muhaddithis. However, Nasiruddin Albani has also long debated the name of Tirmizi Sharif. But was not able to find out the result. 1 Many muhaddithin have also recognized Tirmidhi Sharif as a "Sahih" book. Such as Imam Hakim and Khatib Baghdadi. Hafez Ibn Salah (may Allah be pleased with him) has mentioned this statement in his book Muqaddima Ibn Salah. Then he canceled the set and said that there are several descriptions of Zayf and Munkar in Tirmidhi in proportion to the statement of Imam Tirmidhi. It is not right to call it saheeh. 2 On the other hand, many muhaddiths have named Tirmizi Sharif as "Almusnadul Jame". For example, Hafez Abul Kashem has written the name of Tirmizi on page 3 of his book "Fayyalul Kitab Aljame Liabi Isa Attirmizi" "Almusnadul Jame". 3 Hafez Ibn Khair Ashshabili Rah: writes: The name is also found in two old manuscripts of Tirmizi Sharif. One manuscript is dated 469 AH and the other is dated 582 AH. The first narration is owned by Dr. Mustafa Ajmer in proportion to the statement of Shaykh Abdul Fattah Abu Guddah. He bought it from Hindustan with a lot of money. This is a very old recipe. Less than 3 pages at the end of a volume. The total number of pages is 648. The second text is preserved in Faizullah Afindi in Maktabay. It is clearly written there: Both prescriptions have certificates. Which reaches Imam Tirmidhi. For details read “Tahkiku Ismis Sahih Wa Ismis Jameut Tirmizi” by Shaykh Abdul Fattah Abu Guddah. 2294888675
- والله اعلم باالصواب -
* This Fatwa was translated by Google Translate.
To see the original click here
Related Fatwas
- It is shirk to name the organization by any name other than Islam 9721947825
- Tahkeek of the hadith found in the light of light and the nonsense of the claimants of light 7124991651
- Bukhari's account of the Prophet's attempted suicide 2857131816
- Answers to some of the most common questions about madhhabs 5697116394
- What is the basis of the hadith of the meaning, 7445944398
- Is it right for a student of religion to spread the wings of angelic light and make the way to paradise easier? 8882558337
- Use it loosely after urination and walk around with it 3975254418
- Judging by the analysis, where is the problem to follow one madhhab at a time 8199937162